Your Complete Guide To Custom Engagement Cookies At Sweet Ali

Your Complete Guide To Custom Engagement Cookies At Sweet Ali

Forty percent of all the engagements for the year happen between November and February, which means it's the time of the year to book engagement parties. What makes for a memorable engagement party is spectacular food, and if you are looking to order desserts, Sweet Ali is your place. 

We are dedicated to making personalized sweet treats everyone at your party will love. Now, if this is your first time hosting an engagement party, there's no need to stress. We've put together a guide to help you decide what you'd like to serve at your celebration. 

Here's all you need to know about our custom engagement cookies: 

Chocolate Dipped Oreos

What's better than an Oreo? An Oreo dipped in chocolate. You get your choice of white, dark, and milk chocolate. Say you're having trouble choosing one, no worries. We have a "variety" option so that all your guests can pick which one they like best. 

Once the Oreos are coated in chocolaty goodness, we can top it with a customized image. All you have to do is upload a high-resolution image to your order. Smartphone photos usually work well. 

We package them up differently depending on if you want to serve them during the party or send them home with people in a goodie bag. The options are individually wrapped cello ribbon, individually wrapped in a box, or a box of twelve. This last option is best for those who want to plate the sweet treats themselves. 

Chocolate Pops

The chocolate lovers out there will love our chocolate pops. These no-mess treats are great to snack on while playing wedding bingo or the almost newlywed game. Like the chocolate covered Oreos, the chocolate pops come in milk, dark and white chocolate.  

You can always pick what kind of chocolate you'd like based on your photo or design's colors. In doing so, you can make the image stand out against the pop. 

The minimum number you can order is twelve, which is great for smaller gatherings. If you have a lot of mouths to feed, you can order one for everyone. These come in individually wrapped cello ribbons, so people have the option to take one with them when they leave.  

Krispy Rice Treats

You can't go wrong with the classic Krispy rice treat. Similar to the chocolate pop, they're easy to eat and perfect if you want a dessert that's packaged individually. 

While krispy rice treats usually come in a rectangular shape, you can change that if you'd prefer to mix it up. Hearts and engagement rings are both popular shapes for parties celebrating the soon-to-be-married couple. 

However, it is easier to put an image on a rectangular, so keep that in mind when choosing your shape. Icing and sprinkles are also options that come with Krispy rice treats.

You don't have to have a plain treat to add them on. Use icing to border your image or sprinkles to make the colors in your design stand out. If you aren't a big fan of icing, we'll dip your treats in chocolate for you instead. 

Krispy Treats Cake

Instead of going with a traditional cake, why not mix and up and choose a Krispy Treats Cake? You can go with a single or a double layer for that extra crunchy marshmallow goodness. We do want to note that our double layer is only available for local delivery or pickup.

If you have one photo of the engaged couple that you want everyone to see, the Krispy treats cake is for you. For extra sweetness, top it off with chocolate or vanilla icing.

It's best to go with vanilla if you want to add a pop of color to the cake. Plus, you can ask for matching or complementary sprinkles to go with it. 


Can't choose between the chocolate-dipped Oreos and the Krispy rice treats? There's no need to pick one when you could have them both; that is why we make personalized engagement cookie platters. Not to mention, they come with some other yummy snacks to munch on. 

Pretzels dipped in chocolate, chocolate-covered marshmallows, and popcorn are some of the extras you'll find mixed in with your other delicious desserts on our platters. For those who can't get enough of the chocolate, we'll drizzle some of the popcorn so that you get a taste of it with every bite. 

There are four options to choose from: small, medium, large, and extra-large. These platters are great for all types of gatherings, so if you find that they are successful at your engagement party, be sure to order them for birthdays and anniversaries too. 

Custom Engagement Cookies Photo & Design Ideas

Not only do you want people to enjoy eating these desserts, but you want them to go with the other decorations. There are a ton of fun ideas that you could put on your customized treats. Photos of the happy couple, the wedding date, the future bride and groom's initials are all just a few ideas you can use.

If the bride or groom has already chosen the wedding colors, you can use those for the sprinkles or icing. Choose details that best reflect the soon-to-be newlyweds, and these treats are something you and your guests will be talking about for years to come. 

Order These Desserts Today

You can't go wrong with any of our custom engagement cookies at Sweet Ali. We offer nut-free and gluten-free options so that everyone can enjoy our tasty treats. Although we are based out of New Jersey, we ship all over the nation. 

Get ahead of the engagement party craze and fill out the custom order form now.  Leave the baking to us, and we'll make sure your party is a success.